The sky is for all: Ruskin and the Guild of Saint George

Spring 2024 #45
written by
Grace Crabtree
subscribe

This article was first published in STIR Spring 2024 - Issue 45

In a series of essays, collected in 1862 as Unto This Last, the Victorian polymath John Ruskin (1819-1900) coined the term illth. In contrast to wealth, illth stood for the sense of the devastation brought about by the pursuit of riches motivated by self-interest. Ruskin’s excoriation of the “science of political economy” and the effect of industrialism on the natural world did not go down well at the time and the writer was, in his words, “reprobated in a violent manner”. The Cornhill Magazine, in which the writing first appeared, was forced to discontinue publication of his texts. But, along with many of Ruskin’s works, Unto This Last continued to make waves into the twentieth century nevertheless and had a profound influence on several members of the early British labour movement, including William Beveridge, whose eponymous 1942 report established the principles of the Welfare State. Gandhi even credited his discovery of Unto This Last in 1904 with bringing about an “instantaneous and practical transformation” in his life and ideas. 

Darkening skies

Throughout his early career, Ruskin had become something of a Victorian celebrity, initially through his championing of the artist JMW Turner and the Pre-Raphaelites in his five-volume work Modern Painters (1843-1860) – a vast project which outlived Turner – and then through writing and lecturing on subjects from art and architecture to philosophy, education, and socio-political criticism. Though he spanned several disciplines at once, he was not a generalist; rather, Ruskin was concerned with particulars, paying intimate attention to everything from the vastness of the geological time of mountains to the minutiae of a plant’s anatomy.

This approach of constant looking, writing, and drawing – his diaries and letters were filled with intricate sketches and watercolours – as he travelled in the UK and abroad, revealed to him over the years changes in the environment, from the land to the skies. He saw glaciers melting in the Alps, and discerned a link between deforestation and natural disasters such as landslides. He was profoundly interested in what he called “the architecture of the sky”, and drew from new scientific understandings of the behaviour of light, wind, and clouds. Ruskin, with his artist’s eye, became powerfully attuned to the meteorological changes occurring throughout the late nineteenth century – “hitherto unknown in the courses of nature” – and was one of the first to link this to the burning furnace chimneys of newly-industrialised London. 

Ruskin’s revelation, which married aesthetic observation with scientific study, was widely rebuked when he delivered his ‘Storm-Cloud’ lectures at the London Institution in 1884. However, the fundamentals of this early environmental consciousness did gradually take hold and the Guild of Saint George – which Ruskin had founded in 1871 – commissioned a study in 1907, seven years after Ruskin’s death, on Britain's “smoke problem”, concluding that “the air can no longer be kept clean without regulation”. But Ruskin was concerned with something more than the direct link between industrialisation and the “storm-clouds” and “plague-winds” that so haunted him from the 1870s onwards. They seemed to him of a “malignant quality”, more like “dead men’s souls” than the poisonous smoke of chimneys. Indeed, it was Ruskin who coined the term ‘pathetic fallacy’ – the poetic personification of natural phenomena – as Brian Dillon notes in Suppose a Sentence (2020). More than just metaphorical descriptions, these storm clouds were a force that shattered his complex cosmology of religious, moral, and aesthetic beliefs; they risked shaking humanity, or at least Ruskin’s sense of it, to its very core.

The Guild of Saint George

While Ruskin’s ideas were seemingly boundless, they were often very much grounded in the material world – he advocated looking closely at the world, of working with the hands and with the land. He believed in a holistic education: the cultivation of practical knowledge as well as erudition, and not dividing art, nature, and the economy into separate spheres. He was passionate about education for the working classes, too, teaching at the Working Men's College in London and writing a monthly digest of ideas during the 1870s, Fors Clavigera, addressed to the ‘Workmen and Labourers of Great Britain’. In the first ‘Letter’ of 1871, he wrote:

“I simply cannot paint, nor read, nor look at minerals, nor do anything else that I like, and the very light of the morning sky, when there is any which is seldom, now-a-days, near London has become hateful to me, because of the misery that I know of, and see signs of, where I know it not, which no imagination can interpret too bitterly.”

Founded by Ruskin that same year, the Guild of St George was a way of putting some of these ideals into practice, bringing together arts and crafts with rural economy. Ruskin looked to a medieval and Gothic past to help shape his ideas on art and architecture. Founded initially as ‘St George’s Company’, it was legally constituted in 1878 as the Guild of St George, and like the medieval, pre-industrial organisations of artisans and tradespeople, it would follow principles of more co-operative working, and championed education and happiness over profit, and beauty and craftsmanship over mass-production. 

The Guild’s ‘Code’ was published in an edition of Fors Clavigera. It emphasised the need to “strive to raise [one's] own body and soul daily into higher powers of duty and happiness”. Nurturing the land – “to guard and perfect all natural beauty” – is of great importance. There is also a moral obligation to defy laws or commands when at odds with “what [the Companion] suppose[s] to be the law of God.” In such a case, opposition and disobedience would be permissible, indeed obligatory. Above all, Ruskin believed in the need for ‘meaningful work’, alongside education, libraries, and museums, that would enrich the inner life and not solely provide subsistence for a hard existence. He cultivated a collection of artworks, books, minerals, and medieval manuscripts for the working people of Sheffield – now housed in the city’s Millennium Galleries.

Ruskin Land

We will try to make some small piece of English ground, beautiful, peaceful, and fruitful. We will have no steam-engines upon it, and no railroads; we will have no untended or unthought-of creatures on it; none wretched, but the sick; none idle, but the dead.

—John Ruskin, ‘Letter 5’, Fors Clavigera (May 1871)

Ruskin set aside a ‘tithe’, a portion of his income, for building a ‘National Store’ of food, clothing, books, and works of art for “the common service”. He encouraged others to do the same across the country, with whatever they could spare. This included the purchasing of land: “...buy ever so small a bit of ground,” he wrote in an 1874 issue of Fors Clavigera, “...buy it freehold, and make a garden of it, by hand-labour; a garden visible to all men, and cultivated for all men of that place.” The Guild purchased or received donations of land, including an area in the Wyre Forest, Worcestershire, known as Ruskin Land. Its name more suggestive of a theme park than a National Nature Reserve, Ruskin Land covers 100 acres of ancient oak woodland, orchards, meadows, and farmland. A portion of the land owned by the Guild is managed by the Wyre Community Land Trust (WCLT), which was set up by Guild Companion and Director John Iles in 2007. Both the Guild and the land trust , alongside tenant farmers, local landowners, and organisations such as Natural England and the Woodland Trust, work to sensitively manage the land and to continue Ruskin’s founding intentions. Visitors and volunteers come to learn woodworking, forest and orchard maintenance, and to try other land-based skills and heritage crafts. Ruskin Studio, a renovated barn, provides a space for courses and events, and WCLT hosts educational visits for local community organisations and schools.

Today’s Guild of Saint George, registered as a charitable trust in 1971, a century after its inception, has over 300 members worldwide and a board of volunteer directors, drawn from the membership. The Guild has retained the hierarchical wording in their organisational structure: members are ‘Companions’, while the Chair is known as the ‘Master’. Ruskin was the original Master of the Guild until his death in 1900; since 2019, the post has been taken up by Rachel Dickinson, the first woman to hold the position. Dickinson is an academic in English and – fittingly for a Ruskinian organisation – in Interdisciplinary Studies, writing widely on Ruskin and Victorian culture. The Guild organises events and lectures, and publishes an annual journal, The Companion. In 2000, the Guild also founded a national Campaign for Drawing (now ‘The Big Draw’) encouraging drawing to be considered an essential tool: a “means of obtaining and communicating knowledge”, in Ruskin’s words.

Prophetic fallacy?

Ruskin’s popularity declined after the Second World War, his work increasingly seen as conflicting with shifting societal values. The language he used was often heavily saturated with biblical imagery, and this can be seen in his writing about the Guild, at times both militaristic and religious – “St George’s soldiers”, “Christian ship of war”. The image of Ruskin as a Victorian patriarchal prude has also never quite shifted, and his radicalism in certain fields, from environmentalist to anti-capitalist sensibilities, is sometimes eclipsed by some outdated views on gender, and the occasional veering into nationalist and imperialist sentiment. 

As with many thinkers of the past, contemporary critics are left to grapple with the implications of selecting which ideas to focus on, without glossing over others. In 2019, celebrations of Ruskin’s bicentenary included exhibitions, symposia, and new publications, with a focus on his renewed ‘relevance’ in recent decades, and widening the scope of audiences interacting with his ideas. This centred partly on the early intimations of anthropogenic climate change. Some claims of Ruskin’s prophetic relevancy risk sounding anachronistic, a forward projection of contemporary understanding. Several academics have tempered the temptation of labelling Ruskin an ‘early’ or ‘proto-environmentalist’, an approach which risks “bringing similarities into sharp relief while casting important (and valuable) differences in shadow”, as Sara Atwood writes in ‘The Earth-Veil: Ruskin and Environmentalism’, published by the Guild in 2014. 

Yet from early on there has been a sense that Ruskin saw – and vociferously spoke out about – many issues that do transcend the nineteenth century. Ruskin would surely not be able to comprehend the stark division between knowledge and action in today’s age of urgent climate breakdown. As Atwood continues, perhaps the continued environmental devastation we face is because “the perceptual shift that so worried Ruskin has now been normalised”; in other words, we no longer see things as a “web of relations” but instead as discrete departmental specialisms with little bearing of one upon on the other. Can any individual or organisation hope to address this satisfactorily? Certainly, the work of the Guild and WCLT builds upon Ruskin’s invitation not merely to look as an end in itself, but to see clearly; not only to decry or mourn, but to act and change. Such networks of small-scale initiatives can connect to make a richer whole and provide hope for a shift in consciousness, rather than a descent into darkening skies. As Ruskin said, concluding his first ‘Storm-Cloud’ lecture, “Whether you can affect the signs of the sky or not, you can the signs of the times.”

About the Author

Grace Crabtree works with Stir to Action, and is an artist, writer, and filmmaker.

Spring 2024 #45
subscribe

Suggested reading

The Chartist Foundations of Social Clubs

by
Isabel Thomas
Autumn 2026 #55

Membership Nation:Cultural & economic case for civic renewal

by
Jonny Gordon-Farleigh with Grace Crabtree
Autumn 2026 #55

Radical Space: An Interview with Margaret Kohn

by
Margaret Kohn with Jonny Gordon-Farleigh
Summer 2026 #54

Organising for ownership

by
Hazel Sheffield
Spring 2026 #53
SEE ALL ARTICLES
By clicking “Accept All Cookies”, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy for more information.